Consider a client who has invested in a SIF strategy designed to hedge against sudden equity downturns using Nifty options. They call you in a panic, asking whether they should ’execute’ their long call option when the underlying market index falls significantly below their strike price. As a distributor, your immediate task is to clarify that an option holder only exercises their right when it is financially beneficial, not out of necessity or panic.
Understanding the ‘in-the-money’ condition is the bedrock of explaining why certain hedging strategies may expire worthless instead of being exercised.
A call option grants the holder the right to buy the underlying asset at a pre-agreed strike price. In the Indian market context, this becomes ‘in-the-money’ only when the current market price of the underlying asset rises above that strike price. If a client holds a call with a strike of ₹20,000 and the index is trading at ₹20,500, the intrinsic value is ₹500, making exercise a logical decision to capture that spread.
However, if the market remains at ₹19,500, exercising the right to buy at ₹20,000 would be irrational, as the client could simply purchase the asset cheaper in the open market.
Conversely, a put option serves as insurance, providing the right to sell the underlying asset at a fixed strike price. This becomes ‘in-the-money’ when the market price drops below the strike. If your client holds a put option with a strike of ₹20,000 and the market dips to ₹19,000, they have the valuable right to sell at a price higher than the prevailing market rate.
This specific mechanic is exactly what you must explain to HNI clients who view SIF investment strategies as a form of capital protection rather than just speculative bets.
Failing to distinguish these triggers often leads to misaligned expectations regarding the cost of hedging. If an investor ignores the intrinsic value and insists on exercising ‘out-of-the-money’ options, they are effectively choosing to lose money compared to their current market alternatives. As a professional, your role is to ensure they understand that premiums are paid for the optionality, but the decision to exercise must always be guided by the current relationship between the strike price and the market price.
Always frame these conversations around the investor’s objective to ensure they don’t confuse the cost of the option premium with the potential for profit through exercise.
Nuance
Check Your Understanding
An investor holds a put option on a Nifty-linked SIF strategy with a strike price of ₹22,000. On the expiration day, the Nifty closes at ₹21,700. Which of the following describes the status of the option?
Under what condition would an investor rationally exercise a call option in a hedge strategy?
This is a companion read for Section 21.2 — Difference between futures and options from Pass Certification Examination for Mutual Fund - Specialized Investment Fund Distributors by Akhilesh Gururani, available on Amazon Kindle.
Copyright © 2026 Akhilesh Gururani. All rights reserved.