Pass Certification Examination for Mutual Fund - Specialized Investment Fund Distributors Difficulty: Beginner 2 Questions   5 min read
📌 Chapter 15.7 — Futures pricing

A common situation for a mutual fund distributor arises when an HNI client, familiar with equity mutual funds, asks why the futures price of a commodity like gold or crude oil is trading lower than the spot price. In the world of equity-linked mutual fund schemes, the cost of carry model is intuitive because interest rates and dividend yields are predictable.

However, when you guide a client toward a specialized investment fund or a commodity-linked strategy, this logic often hits a wall. The client might assume that futures prices should always be higher due to storage costs, yet they observe a market in backwardation.

This phenomenon is driven by the convenience yield, which represents the premium market participants are willing to pay for physical ownership of a commodity. Unlike a financial asset, which serves only as a store of value, physical commodities provide immediate utility for production or consumption. If a refinery faces a shortage of crude oil, having the physical barrel today is far more valuable than holding a piece of paper promising delivery in six months.

This urgency creates a tangible benefit for the physical holder, effectively acting as a negative cost of carry that pushes the spot price above the futures price.

For a distributor or relationship manager, acknowledging this is critical when assessing the suitability of commodity-based products for a client’s portfolio. You must explain that these instruments do not always track the simple cost-of-carry model because they are tethered to the physical supply-demand equilibrium of the underlying asset. When a client allocates a portion of their corpus—perhaps keeping in mind the ₹10 lakh minimum investment threshold for certain SIF strategies—they are often chasing diversification.

Failing to explain that these markets can behave differently from standard equity futures can lead to frustration when the client sees their investment value move in ways that defy their expectations of interest-rate-driven pricing.

Properly managing this expectation is a part of your disclosure obligation to ensure the investor understands the risks of market volatility beyond standard financial factors. If you treat all derivatives as if they follow the same textbook pricing model, you risk mis-selling a product that the client does not fully comprehend. Always frame your advice by emphasizing that commodity futures are driven by real-world shortages and availability, not just financing costs.

A robust suitability assessment includes helping the client visualize the difference between holding an asset for its yield versus holding it for its essential industrial utility.

Nuance

⚠️ Nuance
Many candidates incorrectly assume that the cost of carry model is universal and always results in contango, where futures are priced higher than spot. This confusion stems from applying equity-based logic to physical markets. A sharp distributor recognizes that convenience yield is an anomaly specific to physical goods, and realizing that a backwardated market is often a signal of supply tightness is essential for sophisticated client conversations.

Check Your Understanding

Practice Question 1

An investor approaches you, concerned that the gold futures contract they are tracking is trading lower than the current spot price. As a distributor, which explanation best reflects the role of convenience yield?

Practice Question 2

If the convenience yield of an asset increases while financing costs remain constant, what is the expected impact on the relationship between spot and futures prices?

This is a companion read for Section 15.7 — Futures pricing from Pass Certification Examination for Mutual Fund - Specialized Investment Fund Distributors by Akhilesh Gururani, available on Amazon Kindle.

Copyright © 2026 Akhilesh Gururani. All rights reserved.