Consider a client who walks in with a portfolio report, questioning why their diversified equity fund has trailed the Nifty 50 for the past year. They see the benchmark rising but their fund’s alpha—the excess return generated by the manager—is negative. This is the moment where you must explain the reality of active stock selection, moving the conversation away from simple past returns toward the manager’s conviction and strategy.
An active manager does not just replicate the index; they intentionally deviate from it to identify undervalued opportunities or skip sectors they believe are overvalued.
Active management requires deep research into individual companies rather than just betting on macroeconomic trends. By selecting specific stocks, a manager aims to capture higher returns, but this comes with ‘active risk’ or tracking error. If a fund manager identifies a hidden gem in the small-cap segment that eventually scales up, the client reaps significant rewards. However, if the manager’s fundamental analysis proves incorrect or if the sector they favor suffers a temporary setback, the fund may underperform the broader market significantly, leaving the client frustrated.
As an MFD, your role is to ensure the client understands that consistent outperformance is difficult and comes with a price. While regular plans carry higher expense ratios compared to direct plans, the value you provide lies in conducting these suitability assessments, explaining the manager’s investment style, and holding the client’s hand during periods of underperformance. Without your guidance, a client might panic-sell during a period of underperformance, missing out on the long-term recovery when the manager’s conviction finally pays off.
Ultimately, active stock selection is a double-edged sword that demands patience. When you recommend an actively managed fund, you are implicitly endorsing the manager’s skill in navigating market inefficiencies. If your client requires a steady, predictable journey, ensure their allocation is balanced with lower-risk instruments, ensuring their peace of mind is never sacrificed for the pursuit of alpha.
Nuance
Check Your Understanding
An equity fund manager chooses to underweight the banking sector despite its high weightage in the benchmark, believing interest rates will rise. This is an example of what?
Which of the following is a primary risk associated with choosing an actively managed fund over a passive one for a client?
This is a companion read for Section 10.3 — Drivers of Returns and Risk in a Scheme from Ace the NISM Mutual Fund Distributors Exam by Akhilesh Gururani, available on Amazon Kindle.
Copyright © 2026 Akhilesh Gururani. All rights reserved.