📚 PASS Investment Adviser (Level 2) Difficulty: Beginner ℹ️ Info   ~5 min read
📌 Chapter 15.2 — Concept of Wills

Imagine you are reviewing a high-net-worth client’s succession plan, only to discover that the appointed executor is a family friend with no financial background. You note that the estate includes a diverse portfolio of Indian equity, real estate, and unlisted securities. As a professional, you must assess whether the executor’s lack of expertise or potential negligence could trigger personal liability. Understanding the legal threshold of this liability is essential when advising clients on the structural risks inherent in their estate planning.

An executor is not merely an administrator; they are a fiduciary who holds the estate’s assets in trust for the beneficiaries. Under the Indian Succession Act, the executor is legally obligated to act with the highest degree of diligence and good faith. Mismanagement, which encompasses actions such as unauthorized investments, failure to settle debts in priority, or the commingling of personal and estate funds, exposes the executor to personal financial liability.

The executor is essentially a guarantor of the estate’s integrity, meaning they may be held personally liable for any losses resulting from a breach of their fiduciary duties.

In practical terms, this fiduciary duty requires the executor to act as a ‘prudent man’ would when managing his own property. If an executor sells a prime piece of real estate significantly below market value, or fails to pay statutory tax liabilities on time, the resulting penalties and financial damages can be surcharged against the executor personally. This risk is particularly high in India where legal disputes over estate settlement can drag on for years.

When drafting an investment policy statement or advising on asset distribution, an analyst must recognize that a poorly appointed executor effectively turns a planned transition into a litigation hazard.

Consider a case where an executor decides to ‘speculate’ with estate cash reserves in volatile penny stocks to increase the inheritance pool. If those assets depreciate significantly, the beneficiaries have strong legal grounds to sue for the shortfall. The executor cannot hide behind the excuse of ‘good intentions’ if they failed to follow the investment guidelines implicit in their duty of care.

For an analyst, this underscores the necessity of suggesting professional executors or corporate trustees for complex estates to mitigate the risk of amateur mismanagement that could deplete the legacy you were tasked with preserving.

Nuance

⚠️ Nuance
A common misconception among candidates is that executors are immune from liability as long as they do not steal from the estate. In reality, the threshold for liability is ’negligence’ and ‘breach of duty,’ which includes poor decision-making or failure to act according to the law. Even in the absence of fraud, an executor can be held personally responsible for financial losses caused by their failure to prudently manage or invest the estate’s assets.

Check Your Understanding

Practice Question 1

An executor of an estate in India, acting without specific authorization from the Will, invests a large portion of the estate’s liquid cash in a highly volatile mid-cap equity fund to seek higher returns. The fund crashes, resulting in a 40% loss of the invested capital. Which of the following describes the executor’s potential liability?

Practice Question 2

Under the Indian Succession Act, if an executor fails to pay the outstanding income tax liabilities of the deceased from the estate’s assets, leading to penalties, who bears the burden of these penalties?

This is a companion read for Section 15.2 — Concept of Wills from PASS Investment Adviser (Level 2) by Akhilesh Gururani, available on Amazon Kindle.

Copyright © 2026 Akhilesh Gururani. All rights reserved.