📚 PASS Investment Adviser (Level 1) Difficulty: Beginner ℹ️ Info   ~5 min read
📌 Chapter 11.2 — Concepts and Terms Related to Mutual Funds

Imagine you are reviewing a debt-oriented mutual fund’s portfolio and notice a significant exposure to unlisted debentures or private credit instruments. As a research analyst, you cannot simply look up a real-time ’ticker’ price on the NSE or BSE for these securities, because they do not trade actively in the secondary market. This creates a valuation challenge: how do you ensure the Net Asset Value (NAV) remains fair and reflective of the current reality for an investor seeking to redeem their units today?

When market prices are unavailable, Indian regulatory guidelines—primarily those established by SEBI—mandate a structured ‘fair valuation’ process. Funds cannot simply hold these assets at their purchase cost, as this would lead to ‘stale’ NAVs that fail to account for changes in the issuer’s credit risk or broader interest rate movements. Instead, valuation agencies or internal committees must employ models that incorporate market benchmarks, comparable yield spreads, and credit rating migrations to estimate a fair exit price.

Consider a scenario where a mutual fund holds a long-term bond that hasn’t traded in three months. If the credit rating of the underlying company is downgraded, the fund manager must immediately adjust the valuation of that bond downward using an ‘amortized cost’ adjustment or a ‘yield-to-maturity’ model adjusted for the risk premium. If the fund kept the original valuation, it would effectively be inflating its NAV, allowing exiting investors to offload their units at an artificially high price at the expense of those remaining in the scheme.

This process is critical because it prevents arbitrage opportunities based on stale pricing. By using objective, standardized, and formulaic approaches to estimate value for illiquid holdings, funds ensure that the NAV truly represents the liquidation value of the portfolio. For an investment adviser, understanding that these ‘fair valuations’ are subjective estimates rather than empirical market prices is essential for conducting thorough risk due diligence on client portfolios.

Nuance

⚠️ Nuance
A common professional misconception is that ‘Mark to Market’ always implies an active, exchange-traded price. Candidates often struggle when they encounter the term ‘Fair Valuation’ in regulatory documents, mistakenly assuming it is a secondary, optional process rather than the mandatory framework for non-traded assets. Always remember that for illiquid holdings, the ‘market’ is essentially simulated through proxy data, meaning the NAV has a degree of model risk that you must communicate to your clients.

Check Your Understanding

Practice Question 1

A mutual fund holds a block of unlisted corporate debentures that have not traded for six months. Under SEBI guidelines, how should the fund manager determine the daily NAV for these units?

Practice Question 2

Which of the following scenarios presents the greatest risk of ‘NAV dilution’ due to the valuation of illiquid assets?

This is a companion read for Section 11.2 — Concepts and Terms Related to Mutual Funds from PASS Investment Adviser (Level 1) by Akhilesh Gururani, available on Amazon Kindle.

Copyright © 2026 HABSG Consulting